Friday, June 08, 2007

My Presentation

I gave a lecture at work last wednesday. It was the first in a series of meatier topics from people who work in AT&T Online. All Senior Technical Architects have to give a presentation once a year. I choose to present "Design Patterns", which is like the Bible of systems analysis. The concepts are not being used at all in AT&T, as far as my experinece goes.

Some people assumed that I was presenting myself as an expert on this topic, so they gave me poor evaluations. I am certain that is from other Senior Technical Architects. I have rtied to talk to a few one-on-one, and they just won't listen to me. They will not accept the information unless you fit the "guru" stereotype which they have been trained to respect when it comes to Computer Science. I am the anti-guru, they jsut won't accept what I say.

The younger people in the audience loved it, and I believe that they will learn it and use it. I did mention at the beginning that I was only introducing the topic, whetting their appetite. I neglected to say that I am not an expert. I don't think that was an oversight. as I think about it, I know that as soon as I say that, I lose all credibility with experienced engineers. They quickly say to them selves: THEN WHY ARE YOU TEACHING THIS - IF YOU ARE NOT AN EXPERT.

The evaluations were split 60% good - 40% bad or neutral. That is what I expected. I fuly expected to be challenged, so I asked the coordinator to not allow questions until the end. I think that is why, out of the 160 attendees, I got 5 evaluations that "Strongly disagree" that I was knowlegeable about the subject. Since they were not allowed to criticise in real-time, it festered until the end - but then they said nothing. Some actually contacted me after the meeting, playing dumb, to testing my knowlege of the topic, trying to see if I was competent in the topic as a whole. Jerks!

I already have my topic for next year. I will discuss the difference between an inference engine and a rule engine - and promote the use of inference in our systems. Again, I am doing this for the younger engineers. The older ones are hopeless. They are not humble enough to learn anything unless it is being taught by someone who comes across as an intellectual giant - thereby putting them in a humble enough state that they can learn.

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

<< Home